Bad Will Hunting

How bookmakers kicked out racing's best customers – and handed them to the black market

GAMBLINGHORSE RACINGPOLITICS

Ed Grimshaw

11/20/20268 min read

Goodwill is the one asset on a bookmaker's books that no auditor can value and no budget can buy back, and the industry has spent three years burning it for warmth. Online racing turnover has slid from roughly £10bn in 2021-22 to £7.85bn, yet the yield has held at £769m, which is how you shrink a business and keep the profit: you stop serving the people who built it. In the adverts the winner is always grinning; in the back office he is a spreadsheet row marked do not feed.

This is not a tidy trade-off but a transfer, from a regulated market that pays a levy to one that pays nothing and asks nothing. Punters have noticed. The question before a deposit is no longer what the odds are, but what the terms are.

Closed, With Compliments

The Gambling Commission's data request covered 14.9m active accounts at the largest online operators in 2024 and found 4.31 per cent restricted. The telling column is profit: 46.78 per cent of restricted customers were in profit over their lifetime, against 25.42 per cent of active customers. A lifeguard who sacked only the swimmers who could swim would struggle to call that a coincidence.

The industry's defence is respectable in the way a locked door is respectable: a bookmaker is a counterparty, not a charity, and the Commission's chief executive says being a successful bettor is no protected characteristic. He also warned that restriction can push customers towards illegal operators, so the trade cannot say it was not told. The BHA's chairman said in January 2025 that operators seem to want only customers who use "high-margin products such as bet builders". That is the language of a business that wants losers.

Please Hold

Taking your money is instant; giving it back is a process. Nothing is certain but death, taxes and a pending withdrawal, and the hold music, to be fair, is flawless.

SBC News reports that every operator is now automating customer support, and my inference is that automation has made silence cheaper. The recorded message promises that your call is important to us, the only stake the firm has never limited. To hear this message again, press 1; to hear anything useful, stay on the line. A bot cannot apologise for a decision nobody will own, and a script cannot explain it.

The Machine in the Corner

To see how a punter backing a 5-1 shot at Kempton came to be asked for bank statements, start in the corner of the high-street betting shop. For years the industry's most reliable earner was not racing but the fixed-odds betting terminal, on which a customer could stake £100 every 20 seconds on electronic roulette. Ministers called it a social blight and cut the maximum stake to £2 on 1 April 2019, over the objection of a trade that had warned of 4,500 closures.

The harm that so exercised Westminster began, to a considerable degree, in bookmakers' own shops on bookmakers' own machines; that is opinion resting on those facts, and online products have their own record. Yet the same trade has now been deputised to detect vulnerability, which is rather like asking the firm that sold the matches to run the fire brigade and fining it when the engine is late.

The stake cut was a rule on the product; the checks are a rule on the customer. A machine that took £100 every 20 seconds asked, so far as I can establish, for no payslip, while a punter who funds £150 in a month can find an operator asking for papers the Commission says it never required. Scrutiny has landed hardest on the one product where the customer can win.

The Commission could have built its own model of harm. It chose one trigger, applied to everyone, enforced by the industry at the industry's expense, which is the cheapest regulation available and, my inference, the least likely to uncover anything inconvenient. Call it delegation dressed as supervision. There is also a flaw of incentive: a restriction costs a bookmaker nothing when the customer is a winner and plenty when he is a heavy loser, so a regulator that hands enforcement to the industry gets enforcement where it is free. The profit figures above are what that arrangement would produce; they do not prove it.

A Ruler for a Fever

The trigger for a financial vulnerability check is £150 of net deposits in a rolling 30 days, in force since 28 February 2025. That is about £5 a day, or one modest Saturday. It counts money moving through an account; it says nothing about whether the money is surplus or the rent, and nothing about the chasing, the midnight sessions and the reversed withdrawals that signal harm. A ruler held up to a fever.

The checks that follow lean on credit-reference data, which records what you have borrowed and repaid, not what you own, earn or inherit. A pensioner with a paid-off house, on my reading, looks as thin as a student. So the check measures neither risk nor the ability to pay; it measures how readily a customer produces his papers.

Worse, the thresholds are, on my reading, set operator by operator. The man who spreads £140 across five sites is never checked; the loyal customer with one account is. It rewards promiscuity and penalises loyalty, an odd way to protect the vulnerable.

The Better Mousetrap

Bookmakers could have built a smoke alarm, and they are the one party in the country with the data to do it; they built a sprinkler that wants to see your payslip first. They hold years of behavioural detail on every account: stakes creeping up, losses chased, withdrawals reversed, sessions past midnight. A model weighting such markers, while leaving alone the punter who has staked the same sum on the same sort of race for a decade, would find real harm without opening a payslip. That is judgement, untested.

Sirens, No Map

Those who say they are most concerned about gambling harm have had much of their way, and the evidence that it has worked is thin. The regulator's yardstick is the Problem Gambling Severity Index, nine survey questions answered by people about their own gambling. It measures what respondents say, not what happens to them, which is rather like taking a patient's temperature by asking how warm he feels. The Commission's own pages concede the limits of relying on it as a proxy for harm, and Ipsos judged it merely still usable, a low bar for a regulator.

A questionnaire cannot tell you whether a £150 trigger prevented a single bad month, and I have found no published evidence that checks, limits or tools have reduced harm; that is absence in my searches, not proof.

What the industry has built instead is a fleet of ambulances parked at the bottom of the cliff: deposit limits, time-outs, self-exclusion, a statutory levy for treatment, and now a payslip. All of it is remedial and none of it is predictive. Harm is a spectrum of behaviour that is simply bad for the individual, and a ledger of that behaviour is exactly what bookmakers already keep. Nobody has asked them to read it. Plenty of sirens, then, and no map.

Know Your Customer

The industry went for affordability instead of a model, and the cynic's reading is that it did so happily. Kenny Alexander, who ran GVC, now Entain, told the Lords Select Committee in February 2020 that the group asked its VIPs for payslips and proof of wealth, the amount depending on what it believed they could spend. Grainne Hurst, nearly a decade at Entain before taking over the Betting and Gaming Council, now calls requiring bank statements neither frictionless nor practical.

I have seen no evidence that data from the Commission's checks has been misused, and data-protection law constrains it. Punters do say, anecdotally, that checks are used as a pretext for restrictions rather than a safeguard; anecdote is not evidence, though nobody publishes the data that would settle it. So this is inference, not accusation: a firm that knows what you earn knows what you can be offered, and what you can be limited to. It has rebounded all the same: Entain told the City in 2023 that affordability checks had already cost it not far off £100m of revenue.

Separately, and in a case about Turkey rather than customers' finances, Mr Alexander is charged with conspiracy to bribe and conspiracy to defraud over GVC's Turkish business between 2011 and 2018. He is presumed innocent, and a trial is reported to be listed from 2028.

Complain, Repeat

Campaigners welcomed the April 2023 white paper as a win against a powerful gambling lobby. On my reading, affordability was the wedge: once a check exists, every further limit has a rationale. The industry's answer has been opposition, with the strategic subtlety of a man shouting at a speed camera. The Commission says it did not ask for payslips, yet punters keep reporting document requests, and its own pilot admitted that different credit reference agencies can return different results for the same customer. It confirmed the checks anyway, promising to tidy the inconsistency later: a blind eye with a press office.

Complaining about the state of the nation is not a strategy. The industry needs a fresh approach, and the only one worth having is the asset it has been spending: trust.

Bots at the Back Door

When the Racing Post asked six AI chatbots where to bet without affordability checks, two between them recommended eleven black-market bookmakers, so friction now comes with directions. The bot, at least, will tell you where the black market is, which is more than the bookmaker's bot will tell you about your limit.

Thrown to the Wolves

You cannot throw your customers to the wolves and expect them to march for you. On affordability checks the BHA has been loud, its chief executive calling the Commission's decision "self-harm on an immense scale". On the cull of winning customers I could find no comparable campaign, which is absence of evidence from my searches, not proof of silence. A sport that asks its most loyal punters to rally to its cause should say, as loudly, that it wants them as customers.

Who Pays the Undertaker?

Racing's main paymaster is turning customers away at the door, which is an unusual way to keep a landlord in business. Bookmakers put around £350m a year into British racing, and a Flutter executive has told the Racing Post that racing has become unprofitable for the firm. Meanwhile the levy is heading for about £110m, a fifth rise in a row, on falling turnover. The patient's temperature is up, and the doctor has taken it as good news.

A church funded by a collection from a congregation locked outside would face the same arithmetic. So what has to be done? These are my suggestions, not forecasts. Own the audience: a sport that rents its customers cannot complain when the lease ends. Use the leverage: racecourses control the media and data rights bookmakers want, so tie renewals to published minimum stakes and a human appeal. And demand evidence: the Commission should publish its pilot evidence in full before racing's income is spent proving the point for it. Racing has always been a game of chance; it should not also be a game of being the last to find out.

Now Mend It

Six changes would cost the industry little, which is the best evidence that the problem is will rather than means. Tell every customer, before they deposit, the level at which a check or restriction will apply to them, and label commercial restrictions as such. Guarantee a published minimum stake on racing's core markets, and require a named human, not a bot, to explain any restriction within 48 hours. Build harm detection around behaviour, not payslips, and publish how well it works. Let punters prove their means once, by consent, carrying the result between operators. And oblige the regulator to publish what the checks have achieved, in outcomes rather than questionnaire scores, and to test its thresholds across operators rather than within each.

Regulation has tied their hands and tax has emptied their pockets, and there is truth in both. Neither explains why a punter staking his own money is treated as a threat.

Bookmakers adore a net promoter score. Ask a restricted punter whether he would recommend you to a friend, and publish the answer.

Racing was built on a handshake between a man who thought he knew something and another willing to be proved wrong. Bookmakers have withdrawn their hand, and the black market has been quick to shake it.