“Satire so sharp, it cuts deeper than the truth.”
A Committee Promoted itself to a Commission. Racing shouldn’t Salute.
No mandate, no powers, one named paymaster and a budget it won’t disclose. The Gambling Policy Commission wants racing’s evidence, and here are five reasons it should get a postcard instead.
HORSE RACINGSPORTGAMBLING
Ed Grimshaw
11/18/20265 min read
Every high street has a stall selling trainers with three stripes slanting the wrong way, and nobody is fooled for long, but the trader isn’t aiming at long. He is aiming at the half-second it takes a hurried eye to read the name and stop reading. The Gambling Policy Commission is not the Gambling Commission, the statutory regulator created by the Gambling Act 2005, though it sits one word away from it, which is the distance that matters in a ministerial inbox. Its own website calls it a committee, as the consultant Dan Waugh did when questioning its mandate. A committee is what you call yourselves when you have a kettle and a shared document; a commission is what Parliament appoints. Promotion cost one noun and no votes.
It wants evidence by 12 February 2027, and my advice to anyone in racing or betting is to send it nothing, for five reasons.
1. It has a letterhead, not powers
It appointed itself, which is like knighting yourself with a bread knife. It has no statutory powers, the regulator says nobody told it, and its 2028 report is one no minister must open. SBC News noted that the Labour government is the one it will be “hoping to influence”. That is lobbying with footnotes.
Its chosen precedent is the Budd review, which at least had a government mandate. Sir Alan Budd told a Lords committee his knowledge of the industry ended in 2001, six years before the first iPhone, so asking his report to guide the smartphone age is like asking a Nokia 3310 for directions to a roundabout.
A commission with no powers has one asset, which is attendance. It aims to publish what it receives, so your numbers become its exhibits, trimmed and framed by a panel you have just helped to credit.
2. Follow the money, if it lets you
The Commission’s website says its seed funding was “philanthropically provided by Derek Webb”. Webb, who made about $25 million from Three Card Poker, founded the Campaign for Fairer Gambling and helped cut the maximum FOBT stake from £100 to £2, which was serious lobbying, done well.
How much has he given? The Commission won’t say, and Next.io reported that it also declined to say whether its founders are paid from his money. It calls itself independent of “government, political parties and the gambling industry”. Read that slowly: the one name missing is the name on the cheque.
Chief economist James Reade says he has never met Webb, and I believe him. A sponsor whose views are published can save himself the train fare.
3. Meet the jury
Professor Jagjit Chadha chairs, with Reade as chief economist and eight members drawn, the launch says, from “economics, law, public policy, health, academia and sport”. Betting is not on that list, nor are training, riding or owning. Licensed operators on the panel: none. A panel that can explain the sea without anyone on it having got wet.
Reade’s research does cover betting markets, including fifty-one bookmakers across 16,000 football matches. I have read a few, and what takes 45 pages any serious football punter could tell you in two minutes. Why waste hours of academic resource when you can ask the punter?
Racing’s seat, on the published list, belongs to Thomas Savill, a director of Plumpton, whose course has backed a Social Market Foundation plan to lift the betting levy to 20%, plus a half-share in Reade, who co-authored a study putting Ascot’s contribution above £260 million. A witness who arrives with the blueprint endorsed is a witness, not a juror.
Dr James Noyes of the SMF also sits, and SCCG reports he advocated the highest proposed gambling tax rises ahead of the 2025 Budget, which makes him an excellent witness on tax and an odd juror. The Racing Post reported that Webb financially backed an SMF roundtable he chaired. Professor Janet O’Sullivan is a trustee of Webb-founded Gambling with Lives.
None of this is misconduct, and all of it is the point. Statisticians call it selecting on the outcome: recruit from people who already hold the view and you need not rig the verdict, because the guest list has written it. Waugh called the result “a group of people with little prior knowledge of gambling”, and macroeconomic cleverness is not knowing why a serious punter closes an account rather than hand over months of bank statements.
4. You have been "Peeled" before
On 8 January, according to the Racing Post, Matt Zarb-Cousin wrote to fellow reformers that a push on casino platforms would “peel off and neutralise racing”. He is not a member, but the feature names him with Webb and Noyes as key players.
Peel off: separate the best-loved sport from the industry it depends on. Neutralise: turn it from opponent into bystander. The bait, the Racing Post reported, was the prospect of an affordability-checks carve-out, and racing duly sat down. The carve-out went the way of most prospects.
Webb wrote in 2024 that his American associates could not fathom how racing became “so compromised and so tied to promoting the interests of billionaire bookmakers”. That is conditional love: racing may sit at the table provided it is a different animal from the people who pay its bills. You can peel a plaster off a hairy arm, but the trouble is the arm.
Noyes, lead author of the 2020 SMF report proposing a £100-a-month threshold for checks, asked the culture secretary this spring to pause them, and quit the government’s advisory group over the rollout. He says he still backs the idea in principle. The architect wants the building stopped, while remaining a firm believer in buildings.
5. Read the cheque first
Look at who funded any study, because sponsorship tilts outcomes. A systematic review of 75 drug and device papers, by Andreas Lundh and colleagues, found industry-sponsored studies reached favourable conclusions 34% more often (risk ratio 1.34). That is medicine, not gambling, so carry the mechanism, not the size: the sponsor shapes the question, the comparison and the reporting.
The rule cuts both ways, and I would apply it equally to anything bookmaker-funded. Here it is easy: Webb has campaigned for tighter regulation and higher taxes on remote gambling, so you need not guess the destination. The sponsor has typed it into the satnav.
What to do instead
Run a three-question test before posting a word: who can act on it, who paid for the room, and who frames what you send? Nobody, Webb in a sum undisclosed, and a panel composed as above.
The best case for engaging: the Act is 21 years old, harm is real, and Reade has said the Commission could find the 2023 reforms sufficient. But an empty chair does not sign the minutes, and a private body that owes you no answer, no appeal and, so far as I can tell, no Freedom of Information reply is a poor place to leave your numbers.
Take your evidence to people who can act on it: the Treasury, DCMS, the Gambling Commission and select committees. Take it, too, to people with gambling experience and industry knowledge, who have laid a price or backed one, and who must declare their interests like everyone else. Publish a copy yourself, and be independent of everyone, including whoever paid for the room.
And do check the name on the envelope. It’s one word.

